GBM5MGA Management Accounting Assignment Sample
Management accounting gives managers the financial information they need to plan, control costs and make decisions inside the business (Drury, 2018). Unlike financial accounting, it does not follow a fixed format and is not prepared for outsiders. Its value lies in how useful it is to the people running the organisation.
- Subject area
- Accounting
- Word count
- 2,500 words
- Pages
- 10 pages
- Format
- Read online
Sample overview
Free GBM5MGA management accounting sample on Metro Manufacturing covering cost classification, break-even analysis, margin of safety and budgetary control.
1. Introduction
Management accounting gives managers the financial information they need to plan, control costs and make decisions inside the business (Drury, 2018). Unlike financial accounting, it does not follow a fixed format and is not prepared for outsiders. Its value lies in how useful it is to the people running the organisation.
This report applies management accounting techniques to Metro Manufacturing (Metro), a growing manufacturer. Task 1 classifies the costs of a planned new product and explains how each type of cost behaves. Task 2 is written as a report from the CFO to the CEO. It calculates Metroβs current break-even point and tests how it would change after new equipment investment, extra marketing spend and a higher sales commission rate. Task 3 reviews the weaknesses in Metroβs current approach to budgeting and recommends a budgetary control system to reduce its reliance on bank borrowing.
2. Task 1: Cost Classification for Metroβs New Product
2.1 Main ways of classifying costs
Costs can be grouped in several ways, depending on the question a manager wants to answer:
- By behaviour: fixed costs stay the same in total as output changes within a relevant range, while variable costs rise and fall in line with output. Semi-variable costs contain both a fixed and a variable element.
- By traceability: direct costs can be traced to a specific product. Indirect costs, or overheads, are shared across products.
- By function: prime cost is direct materials plus direct labour. Conversion cost is direct labour plus production overheads, which together turn raw materials into finished goods.
- By timing of expense: product costs are attached to units produced and held in inventory until sold. Period costs, such as marketing and finance costs, are charged against profit in the period they are incurred.
2.2 Classification of Metroβs new product costs
Table 1: Cost classification for the new product
| Cost item | Behaviour | Direct or indirect | Prime cost | Conversion cost | Product or period cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct materials | Variable | Direct | Yes | No | Product |
| Direct labour | Variable | Direct | Yes | Yes | Product |
| Indirect materials | Variable | Indirect (overhead) | No | Yes | Product |
| Factory utilities | Semi-variable | Indirect (overhead) | No | Yes | Product |
| Factory building depreciation | Fixed | Indirect (overhead) | No | Yes | Product |
| Production supervisor salary | Fixed | Indirect (overhead) | No | Yes | Product |
| Machinery rental | Fixed | Indirect (overhead) | No | Yes | Product |
| Storage facility rent | Fixed | Indirect | No | No | Period |
| Marketing costs | Fixed | Indirect | No | No | Period |
| Interest on financing | Fixed | Indirect | No | No | Period |
Two points help explain the table. First, a cost can belong to more than one group at the same time. Direct labour, for example, is part of both prime cost and conversion cost. Second, the same expense can be classified differently depending on its purpose. Storage rent is treated here as a period cost because the warehouse holds finished goods awaiting sale. If it stored raw materials used in production, it would be treated as a production overhead.
2.3 Fixed costs of the new product
Table 2: Annual fixed costs for the new product
| Fixed cost | Amount given | Basis | Annual equivalent (Β£) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Factory building depreciation | Β£15,000 | Per year | 15,000 |
| Machinery rental | Β£5,500 | Per month | 66,000 |
| Production supervisor salary | Β£40,000 | Per year | 40,000 |
| Marketing | Β£40,000 | Per year | 40,000 |
| Storage facility rent | Β£600 | Per month (assumed) | 7,200 |
| Interest on financing | Β£2,800 | Per year | 2,800 |
| Total annual fixed costs | 171,000 |
None of these costs change with the number of units produced. Metro pays the same machinery rental and supervisor salary whether it makes one unit or ten thousand. On a graph with output on the horizontal axis and cost on the vertical axis, total fixed cost appears as a flat horizontal line at Β£171,000. Fixed cost per unit, however, falls as output rises, because the same total is shared across more units. This is why higher production volumes are so important to the new productβs profitability.
Figure 1: Behaviour of total fixed costs as output changes (horizontal line at Β£171,000 across all output levels)
2.4 Strategic points for Metro
- Renting rather than buying machinery reduces the upfront investment and the financial risk if the new product sells less than expected. The trade-off is a higher ongoing fixed cost.
- Renting storage space gives flexibility. Metro can expand or reduce capacity as demand becomes clearer.
- Funding choices matter. Financing the launch from internal funds avoids interest costs but uses cash that Metro needs to manage carefully, given its liquidity problems discussed in Task 3.
3. Task 2: Break-Even Analysis and CFO Report
REPORT
To: Arham Rahman, Chief Executive Officer
From: Kabita, Chief Financial Officer
Subject: Break-even analysis and the financial effect of proposed changes
3.1 Background
Metro is planning to expand and is considering three changes: investing in new production equipment, increasing marketing spend for Model 301, and raising sales commission rates. This report sets out Metroβs current break-even position and shows how each proposal would affect break-even sales, the margin of safety and profit. Break-even analysis is a core management accounting tool for understanding how cost structure affects risk (Drury, 2018).
3.2 Current break-even position
Table 3: Current break-even analysis
| Particulars | Β£ | Working |
|---|---|---|
| Sales revenue | 42,000,000 | Given |
| Variable costs | (15,300,000) | Given |
| Contribution | 26,700,000 | Sales β variable costs |
| Contribution margin ratio | 63.57% | 26,700,000 Γ· 42,000,000 |
| Fixed costs | (15,450,000) | Fixed cost of sales + fixed marketing + fixed administration |
| Profit | 11,250,000 | Contribution β fixed costs |
| Break-even sales revenue | 24,303,371 | 15,450,000 Γ· 0.6357 |
| Margin of safety (Β£) | 17,696,629 | 42,000,000 β 24,303,371 |
| Margin of safety (%) | 42.1% | 17,696,629 Γ· 42,000,000 |
Every pound of sales contributes about 64p towards fixed costs and profit. Metro needs sales of about Β£24.3 million to cover its costs. Current sales are 42.1% above that level, which is a healthy safety margin.
3.3 Proposal 1: Investment in new equipment
The new equipment is expected to increase fixed costs by 10% and reduce variable costs by 5%.
Table 4: Break-even after equipment investment
| Particulars | Β£ | Working |
|---|---|---|
| Sales revenue | 42,000,000 | Unchanged |
| Variable costs | (14,535,000) | 15,300,000 Γ 95% |
| Contribution | 27,465,000 | |
| Contribution margin ratio | 65.39% | 27,465,000 Γ· 42,000,000 |
| Fixed costs | (16,995,000) | 15,450,000 Γ 110% |
| Profit | 10,470,000 | Down Β£780,000 |
| Break-even sales revenue | 25,989,077 | 16,995,000 Γ· 0.6539 |
| Margin of safety | 16,010,923 (38.1%) |
Key finding: The equipment raises break-even sales by about Β£1.7 million and reduces profit by Β£780,000 at current sales. The Β£765,000 saving in variable costs does not cover the Β£1,545,000 rise in fixed costs.
The two cost structures give the same profit at sales of about Β£84.8 million (extra fixed cost of Β£1,545,000 Γ· the 1.82 percentage point improvement in contribution margin ratio). Below this level, the current setup is more profitable. The equipment would only pay off financially if Metro roughly doubled its sales, or if it brings benefits not captured here, such as better quality, extra capacity or lower maintenance costs.
3.4 Proposal 2: Additional marketing for Model 301
Marketing spend would rise by Β£700,000, which is expected to increase sales by 8%. For this analysis, the 8% increase is applied to total sales, and variable costs rise in proportion.
Table 5: Break-even and margin of safety after marketing investment
| Particulars | Β£ | Working |
|---|---|---|
| Projected sales revenue | 45,360,000 | 42,000,000 Γ 108% |
| Variable costs | (16,524,000) | 15,300,000 Γ 108% |
| Contribution | 28,836,000 | |
| Contribution margin ratio | 63.57% | Unchanged |
| Fixed costs | (16,150,000) | 15,450,000 + 700,000 |
| Profit | 12,686,000 | Up Β£1,436,000 |
| Break-even sales revenue | 25,404,494 | 16,150,000 Γ· 0.6357 |
| Margin of safety | 19,955,506 (44.0%) |
The campaign raises break-even sales by about Β£1.1 million, but projected sales grow faster still. Profit rises by Β£1,436,000 and the margin of safety improves to 44.0%. Marketing would need to raise sales by only about Β£1.1 million (2.6%) to cover its own cost. The projected 8% increase therefore leaves plenty of room for error.
3.5 Proposal 3: Raising sales commission from 12% to 15%
Higher commission is intended to retain top account managers. Commission is a variable cost, so it lowers the contribution margin. For illustration, the extra 3% is assumed to apply to all sales.
Table 6: Effect of higher commission (illustrative)
| Particulars | Β£ |
|---|---|
| Sales revenue | 42,000,000 |
| Variable costs (15,300,000 + 3% Γ 42,000,000) | (16,560,000) |
| Contribution | 25,440,000 |
| Contribution margin ratio | 60.57% |
| Fixed costs | (15,450,000) |
| Profit | 9,990,000 (down Β£1,260,000) |
| Break-even sales revenue | 25,507,075 |
| Margin of safety | 16,492,925 (39.3%) |
Unless the change prevents the loss of key accounts worth more than its cost, a blanket increase is expensive. Research shows that sales staff respond strongly to changes in how they are paid, so the design of commission schemes matters (Sandvik et al., 2021).
3.6 Summary of proposals
Table 7: Comparison of proposals
| Proposal | Break-even sales (Β£) | Margin of safety | Profit (Β£) | Change in profit (Β£) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Current position | 24,303,371 | 42.1% | 11,250,000 | n/a |
| New equipment | 25,989,077 | 38.1% | 10,470,000 | (780,000) |
| Extra marketing | 25,404,494 | 44.0% | 12,686,000 | +1,436,000 |
| Higher commission | 25,507,075 | 39.3% | 9,990,000 | (1,260,000) |
| Equipment and marketing combined | 27,059,530 | 40.3% | 11,967,200 | +717,200 |
3.7 Recommendations
- Approve the marketing investment. It gives the largest improvement in profit and safety margin. Sales of Model 301 should be tracked monthly to confirm that the 8% uplift is being achieved. If it falls short, spending should be scaled back.
- Delay the equipment investment unless there are clear non-financial benefits. On cost grounds alone it reduces profit at current volumes. Metro should revisit it when sales approach the level where it pays off, or negotiate lower rental or finance costs to reduce the fixed cost increase.
- Replace the flat commission rise with a targeted bonus scheme. Rewarding account managers who exceed targets keeps top performers without raising the cost of every sale.
- Build cash reserves. Metro is below its target cash balance of Β£2.5 million. Improving working capital, for example by negotiating longer supplier credit and collecting customer debts faster, should come before major new fixed commitments.
Students looking for more help with cost-volume-profit analysis, investment decisions or financial planning can explore our Finance Assignment Help service.
4. Task 3: Budgetary Control at Metro Manufacturing
4.1 Background
Metro has beaten its sales targets in recent quarters, yet it keeps running short of cash and relies more and more on bank borrowing. The root cause is the absence of a coordinated budget. Metro has no master budget. Department managers decide their own spending independently, and although the CFO, Kabita, allocates funds to departments, there is no single system linking those decisions together. Natalia, a recent recruit, has seen how structured budgeting improved financial control at her previous employer, Re-Deema. The CEO, Arham Rahman, has asked for proposals to reduce Metroβs dependence on bank loans.
4.2 Problems with Metroβs current approach
Table 8: Weaknesses in Metroβs budgetary control
| Problem | Effect on Metro |
|---|---|
| No master budget | Departmental plans are not coordinated, so spending can exceed available funds |
| Independent departmental decisions | Inconsistent planning and no shared targets |
| No cash budget | Shortfalls are discovered too late, forcing emergency borrowing even when the business is profitable |
| No departmental spending limits | Managers are not accountable for costs, and overspending goes unnoticed |
| No inventory or purchasing budget | Excess stock ties up cash, and purchases are poorly timed against sales (Abdolazimi et al., 2021) |
| No forecasting or variance review | Metro reacts to problems instead of anticipating them |
These problems show why profit and cash are not the same. A business can report strong profits while running out of cash if its money is tied up in stock and unpaid customer invoices, or spent ahead of income.
4.3 Recommended budgets
- Master budget
A master budget brings together all the functional budgets into one coordinated plan. It ends with a budgeted income statement, cash budget and statement of financial position (Sentosa, Wijaya and Limowa, 2023).
- Why Metro needs it: it links the plans of sales, production, purchasing and administration so that they fit within the funds available.
- Information required: sales forecasts based on past trends, order books and market data; production and material costs from cost records; departmental expense estimates from managers; and profit targets set by senior management.
- Sales budget
- Why Metro needs it: sales drive almost every other budget, so the master budget must start here.
- Information required: past sales by product and region, customer contracts, pricing plans and the planned Model 301 marketing campaign.
- Production and inventory budgets
- Why Metro needs them: they set how much to make and what stock to hold, so that Metro produces enough to meet demand without tying up cash in excess inventory.
- Information required: budgeted sales units, target closing stock levels, production capacity and material usage rates.
- Purchases budget
- Why Metro needs it: it times material purchases to match production and supports better negotiations with suppliers on prices and credit terms.
- Information required: material requirements from the production budget, supplier prices, lead times and payment terms.
- Departmental expense budgets
- Why Metro needs them: they give each manager a spending limit and make them responsible for keeping within it.
- Information required: past spending records, planned activities, staffing levels and known cost increases.
- Cash budget
The cash budget is the most urgent need for Metro. It shows expected cash inflows and outflows month by month and highlights shortfalls in advance.
- Why Metro needs it: Metroβs problem is liquidity, not profitability. A cash budget would show when shortfalls will occur, so Metro can arrange cheaper planned finance, delay discretionary spending or chase customer payments, rather than relying on emergency bank borrowing.
- Information required: customer payment patterns from receivables records (Alhassan and Islam, 2021), supplier payment terms, payroll dates, loan repayment schedules, planned capital spending and seasonal patterns from past years. AI-based forecasting tools can also improve the accuracy of cash projections (Challoumis, 2024).
4.4 Strategies to strengthen budgetary control
| Strategy | How it works | Benefit for Metro |
|---|---|---|
| Participative budgeting | Department heads help set their own budgets within company targets | Realistic figures and greater commitment |
| Responsibility accounting | Each manager answers for the costs they control | Clear accountability for spending |
| Monthly variance analysis | Actual results are compared with budget and differences investigated | Overspending and shortfalls are caught early (Musiega et al., 2023) |
| Flexible budgeting | Budgets are adjusted to the actual level of activity | Fair performance comparisons when sales differ from plan |
| Rolling forecasts | The cash forecast is updated monthly to look 12 months ahead | Keeps cash planning current |
| Zero-based budgeting | Every cost must be justified from zero each year | Removes unnecessary spending (Pyhrr, 1970) |
| Minimum cash reserve | A target cash balance, such as Β£2.5 million, is built into the cash budget | Reduces the need for short-notice borrowing |
Recommendation: Metro should first introduce a cash budget and a master budget, supported by monthly variance analysis and departmental spending limits. Once these are working, zero-based budgeting can be applied to overhead departments to release cash. Together, these steps would give Metro early warning of cash pressures and reduce its reliance on bank loans.
5. Conclusion
This report has shown how management accounting can guide Metro Manufacturingβs decisions. Classifying costs by behaviour, traceability and function explains how the new productβs costs will respond to changes in output. The break-even analysis shows that Metro currently has a comfortable 42.1% margin of safety. The extra marketing investment is the most attractive proposal, raising profit by Β£1.4 million. The equipment investment and higher commission rate would both reduce profit at current sales. Finally, Metroβs cash problems come from the lack of a coordinated budget rather than weak trading. A master budget, a cash budget and regular variance analysis would give Metro the control it needs to fund growth without relying on bank borrowing.
Need Help with Your Management Accounting Assignment?
Our specialists support you with cost classification, break-even analysis, budgeting and CFO-style reports. Get an extra 10% off when you order through WhatsApp, and visit Prime Assignment Help to connect with a UK accounting expert today.
6. References
Abdolazimi, O., Shishebori, D., Goodarzian, F., Ghasemi, P. and Appolloni, A. (2021). Designing a new mathematical model based on ABC analysis for inventory control problem: a real case study. RAIRO-Operations Research, 55(4), pp.2309-2335.
Alhassan, I. and Islam, K.A. (2021). Credit management strategies and financial performance of industrial goods sector in Nigeria. Indian Journal of Finance and Banking, 8(1), pp.59-74.
Challoumis, C. (2024). How are businesses leveraging AI to enhance cash flow. In: XVII International Scientific Conference, November 2024, pp.145-178.
Drury, C. (2018). Management and Cost Accounting. 10th edn. Andover: Cengage Learning.
Musiega, A., Nyawira, L., Tsofa, B., Njuguna, R.G., Munywoki, J., Hanson, K., Mulwa, A., Molyneux, S., Maina, I., Normand, C. and Jemutai, J. (2023). Budget monitoring, accountability practices and their influence on the efficiency of county health systems in Kenya. PLOS Global Public Health, 3(11), p.e0001908.
Pyhrr, P.A. (1970). Zero-base budgeting. Harvard Business Review, 48(6), pp.111-121.
Sandvik, J., Saouma, R., Seegert, N. and Stanton, C. (2021). Employee responses to compensation changes: evidence from a sales firm. Management Science, 67(12), pp.7687-7707.
Sentosa, S., Wijaya, A.T. and Limowa, D. (2023). Master Budget in Cost Accounting. SSRN Working Paper 4332871.
Sinaga, S.O. (2024). Analysis of determining the cost of goods production using the full costing method as a basis for determining the selling price of rubber at PT. Sinar Belantara Indah. Luxury: Landscape of Business Administration, 2(1), pp.26-58.
Unlock the full sample
Enter your details to view the complete sample for free.
